Ive been watching this show with my girlfriend since January. There are all these spinoffs and shit so we are like 11 seasons in and we’re only caught up to 2019. It’s actually pretty interesting how completely delusional and insane some of these people are.
Russ isn’t gay but he’s a classic feminine/“metrosexual” southern man and Paola is a stereotypical South American firecracker. They’re one of the more normal couples and are both fairly likable.
I fell into this during the lockdown/stay home/consume era of American history. I didn't intend to - I'd walk in and my wife would be watching it, but I fell in. It's kinda perfect schadenfreude.
A lot of the Americans are just as you'd expect - either a socially awkward dude who wants a hot (well, sometimes), younger woman that they can import and control, or a north of middle aged woman who wants a younger foreign man... that they can import and control.
And a lot of the foreigners come across as - if not outright scammers - grifters who really just want to come here and be attended to hand and foot (while complaining if their mate has to work to, you know, put ANY roof over their head, much like the palace they want to live in).
(Ukrainians come across very poorly in this. In general, sometimes it feels like the show has an intentional isolationist/America first undercurrent. I.e., saying that it's own premise is built on a bad idea.)
The real wildcards are the normal-looking/seeming Americans who do this, as they have to have a back story. They must either be batshit insane, abusive or something... They're not making it work here for a reason that is seldom shown.
I can count on one hand the actually likable, well-adjusted people that have been on this.
FYI, if you like the formula and the freak show, you can skip the spin-offs (other than The Other Way, as it's the same recipe, in reverse - the rest are true reality garbage), as there is a host of these sad-sacks that have parlayed this into a fucking career.
TL;DR: I'm still half-asleep & having my coffee and I, too, watch gay TV. It's a fun freak show.